Browse our
local deli menu
Lake Mary Restaurant – Lake Mary Center
Anytime Breakfast
Served with choice of bagel or toast and choice of french fries or fresh fruit
Create Your Own Omelet
Your choice of any three
Meats: Smokehouse Bacon, Corned Beef, Smoked Ham, Sausage
Veggies: Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Tomatoes
Cheese: American, Swiss, Provolone, Munster, Cheddar, Gorgonzola
The NEO Scramble
Nova Salmon, diced onion & a hint of cream cheese folded into a delicious scramble, topped with Everything Bagel seasoning
Nova Salmon PlatteR*
Slow smoked Nova Salmon on a bed of lettuce.
California Fruit Salad
Fresh cantaloupe, honeydew, pineapple, red grapes, strawberries & raisins, served with vanilla yogurt & topped with toasted almonds
Nova on a Bagel*
Freshly sliced smoked Nova Salmon served on a bagel with cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, & onion
TJ’s Ultimate Omelet
Three eggs, smokehouse bacon, sausage, smoked ham, onions, mushrooms, peppers, potatoes & choice of cheese
NOVA TOWER (FOR 2/FOR 4)
NEW! Thinly sliced Nova Salmon with Capers, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Red Onion, Cucumbers, Cream Cheese, Bagel Chips and Bagels of Choice all stacked vertically.
whitefish salad platter
NEW! Smoked whitefish salad served on a bed of lettuce, tomatoes and onions
with rye bread.
whitefish salad on a bagel
NEW! Smoked whitefish salad on your choice of bagel with lettuce, tomatoes and
onions with a side of fresh fruit.
Double Seeded
New York Style Bagels
Poppy, Sesame, Everything, Plain, Pumpernickel, Garlic, Cinnamon Raisin, Onion & Multigrain
1/2 Dozen | Dozen | Too Dozen
Cream Cheese Schmear
Plain, Chive & Onion, Everything, Garden Vegetable, Jalapeno & Garlic, Nashville Hot & Nova
1/2 lb | 1 lb
Starters
Nova Latkes
Crispy mini potato pancakes topped with sliced smoked salmon & sour cream. Finished with arugula, diced red onion & capers
TooJay’s Famous Potato knish
Filled with seasoned and whipped potatoes
Mini Potato Pancakes
A crunchy sampling of our signature scratch-made pancakes, served with sour cream & applesauce
Loaded Latkes
Our crispy, scratch-made potato pancake bites topped with bacon, tomato, melted cheddar, sour cream & scallions. Big enough to share!
Beer battered onion rings
Served in a basket with remoulade sauce on the side.
Chopped Liver
Our own famous recipe, just like your Bubbe’s. Served with a slice of rye and fresh vegetables.
ROASTED WINGS
NEW! Oven Roasted to perfection. Served with Carrots, Celery and your choice of Ranch, Blue Cheese. Buffalo Sauce, Garlic Parmesan or Thai Chili Sauce served on the side.
Cheese blintzes
Two handmade crepes filled with sweet cheese, served with fruit topping and sour cream.
smoked whitefish dip
NEW! Smoked whitefish dip served with housemade bagel chips and vegetables. Don’t forget the hot sauce.
Scratch sOUPS
Matzo Ball Soup
Our light & fluffy matzo balls in a rich chicken broth with carrots & onions
Chicken Noodle Soup
Loaded with chicken & vegetables – Only Bubbe makes it as good!
Beef Cabbage Soup
Soup of the Day
Crock of French Onion Soup
Topped with a thick layer of Provolone & Parmesan
Deli Classics
Served with coleslaw & a dill pickle on choice of freshly baked Artisan Rye, Wheat, Challah, Wrap or Brioche Bun.
Triple J
Corned beef, roast beef, turkey & Swiss rolled with coleslaw & homestyle Russian dressing
TooJay’s Classic
Corned beef & pastrami. A bit of heaven.
Combo Deli Platter
Choice of any three fresh sliced deli meats served on a bed of lettuce with coleslaw, potato salad, pickle & Artisan rye bread
Hot pastrami
Seasoned, cured and piled sky high.
hot corned beef
Hand trimmed and steamed to bring out the full flavor.
Roast beef
Tender slices of rare roast beef lightly seasoned to perfection.
liverwurst
Only the best Braunschweiger and thinly sliced red onions.
the 6 lb mighty jay
NEW! (Feeds 8-12 People) A piled high, 6 pound sandwich containing layers of turkey, roast beef, corned beef, Swiss, coleslaw, lettuce and tomatoes.
Reuben
Our classic hot corned beef, sauerkraut & Swiss with homestyle Russian dressing on grilled Artisan rye.
Rachel
Our classic hot pastrami with creamy coleslaw & Swiss with
homestyle Russian dressing on grilled Artisan rye
Beef Brisket Dip
Lean brisket, caramelized onions & Provolone, baked in a Challah hoagie with horseradish sauce & French onion au jus.
Deli tower
NEW! 3 Deli meats and 2 cheeses of your choice accompanied with lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers and fresh baked bread all stacked vertically.
turkey breast
All natural, whole breast turkey, hand sliced to order.
turkey avocado
Slow roasted turkey breast, fresh avocado, augula, tomatoes and lemon garlic aioli.
beef brisket
Juicy braised brisket, sliced lean and served hot.
beef tongue
Fresh corned beef tongue cut to order, just how you like it.
chicken caesar wrap
NEW! Grilled chicken breast, fresh romaine and creamy Caesar dressing rolled in your choice of wheat wrap or sun-dried tomato wrap.
Hand Tossed Salads
All entrée salads are served “fully dressed & fork ready” when you dine-in, aka the dressing is on it. Order without croutons for gluten sensitive option.
Ranch, Blue Cheese, Honey Mustard, Caesar, Lite Italian, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Russian and Oil & Vinegar.
Strawberry Citrus
Fresh romaine tossed with raspberry vinaigrette, topped with mandarin oranges, fresh strawberries, red grapes, Gorgonzola & toasted almonds
TooJay’s Chopped
Turkey, ham, hard boiled egg, black olives red onions, crisp greens & garden vegetables tossed with choice of dressing, topped with Gorgonzola, crumbled bacon & artichoke hearts
chicken caesar salad
Fresh romaine tossed with grilled chicken, our own Caesar dressing and croutons.
TooJay’s Cobb
Fresh romaine diced chicken breast, ham, red onions, crumbled bacon, tomatoes, hard boiled eggs & cheddar
crispy Chicken
Crispy fried chicken tenders atop fresh lettuce blend and garden vegetables. Tossed with your choice of dressing. Try it Buffalo Style!
Deli Salads
(Make it a platter or a sandwich)
Served on a bed of crisp lettuce with fresh vegetables and rye bread.
Shrimp Salad
Traditional Chicken Salad
T.J.’s Trio
Enjoy all three – Traditional Chicken, Tuna & Egg Salad
* Not available as a sandwich
Egg Salad
Tuna Salad
Chopped Liver
Too for you!
-Daily Deli Deal-
Choose from Chicken Noodle, Matzo Ball or Soup of the Day.
Cup of Soup & Café-Sized Hand Tossed Salad
Cup of Soup & Half Hand Sliced or Salad Sandwich
Hot Handhelds
Served with french fries, coleslaw & a dill pickle.
Open Faced Tuna Melt
All white Albacore tuna on rye with tomato, Russian dressing and melted Muenster
Grilled Cheese
Choose your favorite cheese & we’ll grill it on your choice of bread.
Philly Grilled Cheese
Thinly sliced roast beef, green & red peppers, onions, American & Provolone on grilled challah
Cuban Grilled Cheese
Our version of the South Florida classic! Ham, corned beef, dill pickles, yellow mustard, Swiss on grilled challah
Classic BLT
Stacked with five slices of smokehouse bacon & served on toasted Challah
HOT HAM & SWISS
Ham & Swiss on grilled Artisan rye bread with a side of honey mustard.
Deli Dogs
Two all-beef franks grilled to perfection
Monterey Chicken Sandwich
Marinated chicken breast with avocado, tomato, swiss cheese, arugula and lemon garlic aioli
Chicken Tenders
Our original tenders with choice of Ranch, Honey Mustard or BBQ sauce
Chicken & Fish
All dinners come with House or Caesar Salad, or cup of soup
ATLANTIC SALMON WITH DILL HOLLANDAISE*
Salmon baked with our dill butter & topped with a silky dill Hollandaise, with mashed potatoes & a fresh vegetable.
EVERYTHING SALMON*
Everything Bagel Seasoning crusted salmon served with potato pancakes & a
fresh vegetable.
garlic chicken pasta
Sauteed with broccoli and sweet peppers tossed with penne pasta in a creamy garlic sauce.
meat lasagna
NEW! Fresh ground beef and ricotta cheese baked with layers of pasta, plenty of mozzarella and topped with provolone and parmesan.
FISH & CHIPS
Two Atlantic Cod fillets lightly battered & flash fried, served with french fries, coleslaw & tartar sauce.
Chicken Capri
Sautéed with mushrooms, artichoke hearts & capers in a lemon butter white
wine sauce. Served with mashed potatoes & a fresh vegetable.
Everything Salmon
Everything Bagel Seasoning crusted salmon served with potato pancakes & a fresh vegetable
Atlantic Salmon with Dill Hollandaise
Salmon baked with our dill butter & topped with a silky dill Hollandaise, with mashed potatoes & a fresh vegetable
Burgers
Pastrami Burger
NEW! Juicy sirloin rolled in our pastrami rub and topped with tender pastrami, caramelized onions, Swiss and chipotle mayo.
Patty Melt*
Grilled burger topped with chipotle mayonnaise, caramelized onions & Swiss on grilled Artisan rye
Build Your Own
All burgers are served on a brioche bun. Includes choice of cheese & one sauce.
1. Choose your burger
USDA Choice Ground Beef, Crispy Chicken, Grilled Chicken or Black Bean Patty
2. Choose your cheese
Choice of American, Cheddar, Swiss, Provolone, Muenster, Gorgonzola
3. Add toppings
Grilled Onions, Grilled Green Peppers, Sautéed Mushrooms .79
Beer Battered Onion Ring .99
Fried Egg 1.99
Bacon 2.99
Avocado 2.99
4. Choose sauce
Chipotle Mayonnaise, Lemon Garlic Aioli, Horseradish Sauce, Remoulade, BBQ Sauce, Salsa
Classic Comforts
All dinners come with House or Caesar salad, or cup of soup.
TooJay’s Shepherd’s Pie
Ground beef, tender vegetables topped with mashed potatoes & melted Muenster
Country Fried Steak
Homestyle Country Fried Steak & mashed potatoes topped with country gravy & served with a fresh vegetable
Beef Brisket Platter
Lean, tender brisket & crisp potato pancakes topped with mushroom demi-glace, served with a fresh vegetable
Fish & Chips
Two Atlantic Cod fillets lightly battered & flash fried, served with french fries, coleslaw & tartar sauce
Traditional Turkey Dinner
Tender oven roasted turkey, mashed potatoes & cornbread stuffing, topped with our turkey gravy. Served with a fresh vegetable & cranberry sauce
Side Items
Vegetable of the day
Small French Fries
Basket of French Fries
Basket of Beer Battered Onion Rings
Mini Potato Pancakes (3)
Coleslaw
Potato Salad
Small Caesar Salad
Small House Salad
DESSERTS
Killer Cake
Our most famous dessert. If you like chocolate, look no further
Cheesecake with Strawberries
Our homemade New York style cheesecake with graham cracker walnut crust topped with garden fresh strawberries and purée
Cheesecake
Our homemade New York style cheesecake with graham cracker walnut crust
Carrot Cake
We’ve taken this traditional favorite to new heights. Rich in carrots & layers of delectable cream cheese icing
Coconut Cake
White vanilla cake, layered with classic white frosting & coconut, garnished with coconut flakes
Chocolate Layer cake
Three layers of moist chocolate cake separated by rich chocolate mousse, covered with our special fudge frosting
Banana Dream
Moist banana cake, rich banana cream, chocolate chips, walnuts & milk chocolate icing – Irresistible!
Key Lime Pie
Made with authentic key limes, a scratch made graham cracker crust, finished with fresh whipped cream
Mini Black & Whites (3)
Our legendary shortbread cookies smothered in chocolate & vanilla icing
Brownie
Rich with chocolate
Chocolate Marble COffee Cake
NEW! Three slices, or the whole cake!
Tollhouse Square
The ultimate “Blondie”. Loaded with chocolate chips & walnuts
Rugalach (3)
Cinnamon, Chocolate, Raisin, Raspberry, Apricot or No Sugar Added Strawberry. Ask us about our seasonal flavor.
Coconut Macaroons (3)
Sweet coconut goodness! Chewy & moist on the inside, crispy golden on the outside. Choice of Chocolate Iced or Plain
Cheese Blintz
Two handmade crepes filled with sweet cheese. Served with hot fruit topping & sour cream
Fresh Baked Cookie
Beverages
Arnold Palmer
Lemonade & Iced Tea
Assorted Fruit Juices
Bottled Water
Canned Soda
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi
Dr. Brown’s Sodas
Cream, Diet Cream, Ginger Ale, Root Beer, Black Cherry, Diet Black Cherry, Cel-Ray
Florida Orange Juice
Fountain Soda
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Dr. Pepper, SoBe Life Water Yummy Pomegranate*
Fresh Brewed Coffee
Bottomless Cup
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
Unsweet or Sweet
Gourmet Hot Tea
Organic & Gourmet Selections
Lemonade
Martinelli’s Apple Juice
Milk
Peach Tea
Freshly brewed unsweet or sweet iced tea flavored with peach purée
San Pellegrino 300ml
Strawberry Lemonade
Beer & Wine
Prices reflect wine by the glass, but bottles available where applicable.
Domestic Beer
Budweiser, Bud Light, Michelob Ultra, Yuengling Lager
Specialty Beer
Stella Artois, Sam Adams, Truly Hard Seltzer (Berry), Shocktop, Dogfish Head 60 minute IPA
Mimosa
Create your ultimate mimosa! A full split of champagne served with a carafe of Florida orange juice.
Whites
CK Mondavi White Zinfandel, Ruffino Pinot Grigio, Robert Mondavi Chardonnay, J. Roget Brut Champagne
Reds
7 Moons Red Blend, Josh Cellars Cabernet
Signature Benedicts
Served with two poached eggs topped with Hollandaise & chopped scallions.
Served with our famous home fries.
TooJay’s Benedict
Smoked ham & tomato on a sourdough English muffin
Nova Salmon Benedict*
Smoked Nova Salmon, tomato, red onion & capers on a sourdough English muffin
Breakfast served until 11:00 am Monday-Friday & until 2pm Saturday & Sunday.
Products & offerings are subject to change.
Omelets & Eggs
Served with choice of bagel or toast & choice of our famous home fries, oatmeal or fresh fruit.
Create your Own Omelet
Your choice of any three:
Meats – Smokehouse Bacon, Corned Beef, Smoked Ham, Sausage
Veggies – Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Jalapeno, Tomato
Cheese – American, Swiss, Provolone, Muenster, Gorganzola
Pastrami & Swiss Omelet
Three eggs, Pastrami, & Swiss
T.J’s Ultimate Omelet
Three eggs, smokehouse bacon, sausage, smoked ham, onions, mushrooms, peppers, potatoes & choice of cheese.
The NEO Scramble (Nova, Eggs, & Onion)
Nova Salmon, diced onion & a hint of cream cheese folded into a delicious scramble, topped with Everything Bagel seasoning
Corned Beef Hash & Eggs
Grilled with two eggs any style
Two Eggs
Served any style with choice of smoked ham, sausage links or smokehouse bacon
Three Eggs
Served any style with choice of smoked ham, sausage links or smokehouse bacon
Wraps & Sandwiches
Breakfast sandwiches served on choice of a bagel or brioche bun with our famous home fries or cheese grits.
Egg Sandwich
Served any style with choice of cheese & choice of smokehouse bacon, sausage patty or smoked ham
Waffle Sliders
A freshly baked half Belgian waffle with scrambled eggs, American choice of smokehouse bacon or sausage patty, served with syrup for dipping & a side of our famous home fries
Veggie Scramble Wrap
Egg whites, spinach, onion, mushrooms & Swiss, served with salsa
Nova On a Bagel*
Served with fresh fruit
Morning Specials
Breakfast Combo Platter
Belgian waffle, two eggs, sausage links & smokehouse bacon, served with toast or bagel & choice of our famous home fries, oatmeal or fresh fruit
Country fried steak & Eggs
Generous portion of country fried steak topped with our homemade sausage gravy, served with two eggs & our famous home fries
California fruit salad
Fresh cantaloupe, honeydew, pineapple, red grapes, strawberries & raisins, served with vanilla yogurt & topped with toasted almonds
Belgian Waffle
Served with butter & breakfast syrup, topped with whipped cream
Add Hot Fruit Topping or Strawberry Topping.
French Toast
Thick slices of our Challah flavored with vanilla, nutmeg & cinnamon, topped with powdered sugar.
Chicken & Waffles
Belgian waffle topped with crunchy chicken tenders, served with breakfast syrup & Buffalo hot sauce on the side
Avocado Toast
The Classic
Creamy avocado served on toasted wheat bread, topped with arugula, cucumber, diced tomatoes & a lemon garlic aioli drizzle, served with two eggs any style
The BLT
Creamy avocado served on toasted wheat bread, topped with arugula, diced tomatoes, chopped bacon & lemon garlic aioli drizzle, served with two eggs any style
The Nova*
Creamy avocado served on toasted wheat bread, topped with thinly sliced Nova Salmon, red onions & capers, sprinkled with Everything Bagel Seasoning & served with two eggs any style
À La Carte
Smokehouse Bacon
2 slices or 4 slices
Sausage Links (3)
Sausage Patties
Sausage Gravy
Biscuit & Sausage Gravy
Corned Beef Hash
Ham Steak
Cheese Blintz
Muffin
Blueberry, Cranberry, Chocolate, Bran
Danish
Apple, Blueberry, Cherry, Cheese, Cinnamon, Prune
Mini Potato Pancakes (3)
Bagel & Cream Cheese
Poppy, Sesame, Everything, Plain, Pumpernickel, Garlic, Cinnamon Raisin, Onion, Multigrain
Toast or Biscuit
Choice of Artisan Rye, Wheat, Challah, served with butter or jelly
Our Famous Home Fries
Cheese Grits
Bowl of Oatmeal
Choose TOO toppings: Brown Sugar, Raisins, Fresh Strawberries, Toasted Almonds
Fresh Strawberries
Fruit Salad
Prices are subject to change.
TooJay’s Favorite
Vegetarian
Gluten-sensitive
2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice, but calorie needs vary.
* Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, nova salmon or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions